FINICKY FRANKS

9520 Calhoun Rd, Omaha, NE 68112, United States
+1 402-451-5555
$$$ New American restaurant , Restaurant
(382 Reviews)
Price Range $20–30

Finicky Franks sits quietly within a strip mall on Calhoun Road, and its unassuming exterior belies the thoughtful dining experience inside. This New American restaurant offers a cozy, intimate setting that balances warmth with a touch of refined style — think classy decor that doesn’t feel over the top, paired with attentive but relaxed service.

The atmosphere here is ideal for diners looking for a comfortable evening out without the bustle or noise that often fills busy restaurants. The staff shows a clear commitment to hospitality, taking care to keep things moving smoothly while maintaining a friendly and genuine approach. This lends itself well to both casual dinners and small gatherings where conversation matters.

Finicky Franks is best appreciated by those who enjoy classic comfort dishes crafted with care and some inventive flair. The kitchen leans into hearty, satisfying plates such as the Fried Chicken Dinner and Meatloaf, alongside standouts like the Crab Cake Sandwich and the Beast Burger topped with an egg. Their artisan and meat pizzas offer a pizza experience that’s a bit different from your average pie, and sides like Truffle & Romano Fries or cinnamon-spiced ice cream with tortilla chips add unique finishing touches.

Locals often point to the standout seafood selections — crab-crusted walleye and shrimp scampi get particular praise — making this a good spot if you want something a bit out of the ordinary but still grounded in familiar flavors. The portions come through hot and well-seasoned, and the accompanying salad and vegetable options provide a balance that keeps the meal feeling thoughtfully complete.

Because the restaurant’s space is snug, it’s wise to reserve a table, especially on weekends or evenings when the place tends to fill up with regulars and neighborhood visitors alike. The noise level remains comfortably moderated, which means you can hear your company without shouting — a detail that locals appreciate as it keeps conversations intimate and the evening relaxing.

Overall, Finicky Franks suits anyone drawn to tried-and-true American flavors accompanied by a few creative twists, served in a setting that encourages lingering over good food and conversation. It’s a place where families, couples, and small groups can settle in for an unpretentious but polished dinner experience in Omaha’s northwest side.

Highlights
Has fast service
Serves great cocktails
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
What they serve
Serves alcohol
Serves beer
Serves cocktails
Serves coffee
Serves comfort food
Serves food
Serves organic dishes
Serves small plates
Serves spirits
Serves wine
Best for
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Has catering
Serves dessert
Has seating
Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot

Openings Hours

Checking

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

5:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Wednesday

5:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Thursday

5:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Friday

5:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Saturday

5:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Sunday

Closed

382 Reviews
Mad Buy

04 Jan 2026

This is truly a wonderful little gem of a restaurant. Pulling up to it, you don't think too much of it being in a strip mall. When you walk in, it is a cozy and very nice establishment. The server and staff were extremely helpful and friendly. The drinks were well made and refreshing. We ordered the crab cake appetizer which was rich and brimming with flavor. The BLT Soup was the special and was creamy and hearty. The Pork Tenderloin was way too big for the bun and I believe that is the correct way to serve pork tenderloin sandwiches. It was really moist and the breading was perfect. The steak sandwich was also loaded with mushrooms and it was a healthy serving size. Finally, the Walleye Special melted in my mouth - moist and buttery. I will definitely be visiting here again.

Dan Muths

22 Dec 2025

Finicky Franks is one of those places we wish we would’ve started going to sooner. We had heard about it for years, and once we finally went, it quickly became one of our absolute favorite spots. We now bring friends and family here all the time, and it never disappoints. The staff and owners are truly first-class—welcoming, attentive, and genuinely caring about your experience. You can tell they take a lot of pride in what they do. The food is phenomenal—always fresh and consistently top-notch—and they make some of the best lemon drop martinis in town. Every visit reminds us why we keep coming back. Can’t say enough good things about this place. If you’re looking for great food, great people, and a place you’ll want to share with others, this is it.

Bob Schulte

20 Dec 2025

This place is a Omaha treasure. Tucked away in a place you’d least expect, it does everything right. The food is delicious comfort food, the service is even better, and they have somehow mastered the art of delivering ambience that is not stuffy and also manages noise. So many restaurants just can’t figure out how to keep noise levels down, which can ruin a nice evening. We love this place!

Tony Jaffe

20 Nov 2025

We loved the atmosphere, very classy decor. Great service and great food. The crab crusted walleye was killer and the prime rib was good. Food came out hot and delicious and the staff filled my water glass a dozen times. Make a reservation because the venue is small.

Chad Palmer

10 Nov 2025

I've wanted to try Finicky Franks for over a year now after seeing them listed on Omaha Food Lovers and following their Facebook page, all I can say is I'm so glad I finally got to come. I had the crab crusted walleye... BRILLIANT, full of flavor, excellent crust and the steamed green beans were prefect. My wife had the prime rib and she loved it, very tender, great flavor with excellent au jus. Win win! And I won't forget the salted caramel cheesecake Service was great, well designed bar atmosphere.. we'll be back to try the daily menu!

malachite

07 Nov 2025

Friends told us about Finicky Frank's and decided it was time to check them out. Highly recommend making a reservation and as well as reserving their specials as they sell out very quickly. Saturdays is fried chicken and so glad we reserve 2 plates .. so flavorful and tender and perfectly seasoned It comes with mash potatoes, chicken gravy and cream corn and a dinner roll. I cannot stop thinking about those crab cakes.. We also got the margarita pizza which was also delicious!! I did have my eyes on the artisan pizza.. curious on the cinnamon balsamic and I love me some goat cheese. Drinks: Manhattan and Margarita Staff was super friendly and the interior decor was lovely. Thank you for a wonderful experience

Bryan Andersen

18 Oct 2025

Although this restaurant is in an unusual location (next to a gas station), you totally forget that little annoyance once you enter. The serving staff are kind, friendly, and efficient. The decor and atmosphere are conducive to good conversation and casual dining. It was our anniversary and we wanted to celebrate at a nice, but not too fancy, place. Finicky Frank's filled the bill exactly. We arrived early to avoid a wait -- good thing, because it soon began to get busy on a Saturday evening. We started off with the crab cakes appetizer -- loved them! Two thick cakes with good crab flavor, nicely crusted, served with salad fixings and aioli sauce on the side. Delicious! Saturday's special is Fried Chicken and my wife selected that. Half a chicken served with mashed potatoes, creamed corn, dinner roll & jam, and even a bowl of vanilla bean ice cream for dessert. She could not eat it all; that meant a take home lunch for tomorrow. I chose the Seafood Enchilada and it was amazing! Large, hot tortilla stuffed with salmon and spinach with shrimp on top covered with garlic Alfredo sauce. Good portion size so that I could take half home for later enjoyment. It was a wonderful spot to celebrate a special day!

Join the FINICKY FRANKS Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.